The Leader Squeeze is Real. Here’s What To Do About It

Caught between pressure from the top and the weight of their teams, today’s people leaders are under more stress than ever. Here’s how organizations can shift their systems before stress becomes burnout.

 

The Pressure No One Talks About

You don’t have to be in HR to feel it, but if you are, you’re probably carrying it more than most.

Across industries, team leaders and managers are quietly burning out. Executives are pushing for higher performance with fewer resources. Teams are overwhelmed, under-connected, and looking for guidance. And managers are stuck in the middle, expected to be the glue that holds it all together.

At Pavelka, we call this The Leader Squeeze. And if we don’t address it, the cost won’t just be human—it will be cultural, operational, and ultimately, financial.

 

This Is Not a Manager Problem—It’s a Business Problem

Managers aren’t just another layer in the org chart. They’re the single greatest influence on engagement, retention, and team wellbeing. 

Gallup research shows that managers account for 70% of the variance in employee engagement. When they’re supported, teams are energized, productive, and loyal. When they’re not, the ripple effects are immediate:

  • Stress spreads
  • Communication stalls
  • Motivation dips
  • Turnover rises

 

What’s Causing the Squeeze

It’s not just about the workload. It’s about the system.

  • No leadership training
    58% of managers have never received formal leadership training and development.
  • Promotion ≠ preparation
    Many are promoted for technical skills, not people leadership.
  • Work-life blur
    60% of managers struggle to set boundaries and maintain balance.
  • Remote and hybrid isolation
    Fewer face-to-face interactions with peers and senior leaders leads to a sense of disconnection.
  • No space to lead
    Delivery tasks and back-to-back meetings leave little room for focused work, coaching, and culture-building.

 

“We expect managers to be culture carriers, problem solvers, and performance drivers—all while being available 24/7. That’s not sustainable leadership. That’s a recipe for exhaustion.”
Jessie Pavelka, CEO & Co-Founder

 

From Squeeze to Support: 5 Ways to Shift the System

We won’t fix systemic pressure with a meditation app. This calls for real organizational change—and it starts at the top.

  1. Redefine the Manager Role

Stop treating managers as pressure absorbers. Recognize them as cultural linchpins. Align expectations with capacity and give your people the space to lead, not just react.

  1. Build Better Leaders

Leadership isn’t innate; it’s developed. Invest in training, coaching, and communities that help managers build confidence and competence.

  1. Cut the Noise

Overwhelm thrives without clarity. Help managers focus on what matters—and say no to what doesn’t. Streamline goals, reduce task clutter, and revisit what “must-do” really means.

  1. Show, Don’t Just Tell

Encouraging people to log off at 5 doesn’t work if their leader is emailing at 9. Boundaries need to be modeled by senior leadership in order to stick.

  1. Close the Feedback Loop

Managers need more than performance reviews—they need space to speak up. Create channels for upward feedback and involve them in decision-making, especially around hybrid, wellbeing, and culture initiatives.

 

Want to Go Deeper?

Our full Leader Squeeze Guide includes self-assessments, reflection tools, and practical next steps for teams, HR leaders, and executives to take action.

👉 Download the Leader Squeeze Guide

 

Final Thought

We can’t afford to keep squeezing the people we rely on most.

When you invest in your managers, you’re not just protecting performance—you’re shaping the culture your organization depends on.

More from the blog

The Leader Squeeze is Real. Here’s What To Do About It

Caught between pressure from the top and the weight of

Why Your Employee Engagement App Is Failing (And What to Do Instead)

Digital employee engagement platforms promised to revolutionize workplace connection. HR

13 Honest Truths About Employee Engagement HR Leaders Need to Hear (and What to Do About Them)

Employee engagement numbers haven’t budged much in the past decade.

Get Started

Are you ready to educate, inspire, and empower a healthier workforce?

Join us to champion your team’s vitality and steer your business to prosperity.

Thank you for contacting Pavelka. Any personal data that you submit using this contact form will be used to respond to your inquiries and send you updates. We will not share your personal data with a third party without first sending you a processing notice. Please refer to Pavelka’s Privacy Policy for more information on how we handle personal data.

Pavelka combines the power of technology with human support

With our human-first approach, we work with you to create personalized, intuitive programs:
  • Programs built for your specific challenges.

  • A library of engaging resources.

  • Cutting-edge wellbeing platform to create personalized, intuitive, and seamless employee experiences.

Best practice approach to organizational health includes:

  1. Discovery process to identify areas of improvement.

  2. Customized pathways aligned to your challenges.

  3. Focus on leaders to create lasting, positive change.